- Art supplies: pastels, markers, pencils, pencil sharpeners, erasers, ink, ink pads, brushes, palettes, glue guns, glue, stickers, calligraphy supplies, coloring books, sketch pads, unpainted canvases, acrylic/oil/enamel paint, mediums, gesso
- Stained glass: materials, supplies, and tools
- Craft kits: Bucilla kits, embroidery, cross-stitch, latch hook, candle making, diamond art
- Scrapbooking & junk journals: full sheets of paper, stickers, ephemera, brads, decorative paperclips, dies, stamps, decorative cutouts, embossing powders, paper punches, embellishments, scrapbooks, journals
- Die-cutting machines in good working order (Sizzix, Cuttlebug, Cricut, or similar)
- Craft tools: craft storage containers and drawers, button machines, cookie cutters, cutting dies, drawing tools, hole punches, paper cutters, rubber stamps, craft and sewing scissors, stencils
- Fabric & textiles: sewing machines in good working order, portable embroidery machines, sergers, fabric bolts, remnants (18"x18" or larger), faux fur, leather, appliques, patches, ribbon, trim
- Jewelry: all types, broken or whole — beads, bells, chain, charms, findings, gems, pendants, studs, parts, pieces, supplies, tools, wire, jewelry bags, crystals
- Fiber arts: cross-stitch kits and materials, embroidery hoops and frames, looms, untangled yarn, knitting needles, crochet hooks, kits, embroidery floss, needle punch, felting supplies, clean unspun wool, needlepoint supplies and kits, plastic canvas, spinning supplies
- Clay, molds, and tools; woodworking supplies, wood burners, leather tools, metalworking tools, punches, stamps
- Sewing: buttons, fasteners (snaps, hooks, eyelets), iron-on transfers, machine feet, marking chalk, notions, patterns, scissors, tape measures, thimbles, thread (spools and embroidery), trim, zippers, sequins
- Vintage: trinket holders, miniatures, handkerchiefs, doilies, quilts in good shape, silk scarves, vintage kits and holiday kits, Bucilla, vintage game pieces, vintage wrapping paper, playing cards, postcards, baskets
- Art, craft, and fiber-arts books; sealed unopened puzzles
- Holiday craft kits and creative supplies (not decorations, Christmas trees, or wreaths)